The Pack Finish


Hi!

We made it! The Nov 1st early deadline is now behind us, and my seniors definitely put in the hard work. It's all downwind from here to finish up the rest of the supplementals for regular decision schools. But it's not quite time to relax yet, because now the waiting game begins.

Parents ask me all the time what admissions officers are really looking for when they read applications. It's quite simple: something they can write down.

At a selective school, a reader might spend ten minutes on your kid's file. They give it a few ratings and then write a couple of lines that go to committee. Those lines are the pitch. If the reader can't write a clear one, there's nobody in the room arguing for your kid.

Here's roughly what those notes look like. The kids are made up, but the style is real:

Deny: Solid student at a strong school. Clubs, NHS, soccer. Essay about grandmother, generic. Nothing to move.
Admit: Competitive private school, hardest track available. Sailor - noticed her club's junior boats kept breaking, taught herself fiberglass repair, now runs a monthly fix-it day where kids learn to repair their own boats. Essay is about that, specific and funny. Counselor calls her one of the most self-directed kids in years. Champion this.

The deny kid isn't a bad kid, and that note isn't mean. It's just empty - the reader had nothing to write. Most good students end up somewhere in the middle of the pack. Harvard's readers actually had a name for it: "standard strong." Smart, busy, nice, and hard to tell apart from the next file.

I'm a sailor, so I think about it like a regatta. Mid-fleet kids are fast. They're in the pack because they went where everyone else fast went. The kid on the podium, though, usually isn't much faster - she just saw a shift nobody else saw and committed to it. But when fifteen boats cross the line together, the race committee can barely get the sail numbers down. That's what a standard strong file is like for a reader. (Standing out isn't a guarantee, however, as schools have needs we never see, but it gives your kid a real shot.)

So the answer is to do more, right? Not necessarily. Another club or another AP is just sailing harder in the same pack. So how do you find a shift to catch?

What actually works is leaning into whatever your kid genuinely cares about and going deeper instead of wider. If they don't know what that is yet, that's completely normal. Just skip "what's your passion" - I've never met a sixteen-year-old who didn't freeze at that question.

Ask them when they lose track of time, what they do that nobody makes them do, or what they complain about and secretly want to fix. The answers are usually small and a little quirky, and that's a good thing. Small and specific is exactly what a reader can write down.

It looks like this: the kid who loves baking doesn't need to join three more clubs - she starts selling to neighbors, figures out her costs, and learns why her sourdough sells and her muffins don't. The kid who's always complaining about cafeteria food surveys his classmates and takes the results to the school board. The kid who races sailboats starts coaching the juniors at his club and builds them a customized practice plan based on a data analysis of their performance. None of these are huge. But a reader can write every one of them down in a sentence.

This doesn't mean every activity has to match the major. It's fine for the pre-med kid to spend every spare hour in band practice, or for the future engineer to rebuild his boat instead of joining robotics. Readers can tell when a kid has picked up activities just to look the part, and it usually reads as forced. What does matter is that the major makes sense alongside everything else - the classes they chose, what they write about, what their teachers say about how they think. The engineer who rebuilt his boat is already telling an engineering story. He doesn't need another club or summer program to prove it.

If you'd like help digging into this more with your student, I'm always happy to talk :) Plan a 30 minute meeting with me soon.

But most of all, let them keep doing the things they love, because that will be the shift to catch to break out from the pack.

Until next time,

Nikki

Nikki Bruno // Student Coaching Services

College admissions counselor Nikki Bruno helps high schoolers get in — without losing themselves in the process. Expect straight talk on applications, executive function, and the stuff no one else is saying out loud.

Read more from Nikki Bruno // Student Coaching Services

Hi! Man, it’s been a while! The shop has been heads-down on senior essays and marketing has very much taken the back burner. (Low key, are any of your kids looking for a social media marketing internship? raises hand Send help.) And, of course, I’ve been sailing, and talking to coaches at regattas. I even got to sail with some of my college teammates recently at a nationals, which goes to show how long this community sticks with you. November 1st is a little over three weeks out. For seniors...

Hi! It's been a minute since we've last talked. The end of the summer has been busy! Helping my seniors finalize the outlines and first drafts for all of their essays, onboarding juniors who are starting to dig into the recruiting process, gearing my sophomores and freshmen up for a new school year, and of course sailing my own regattas. I'm on the way to one right now (don't worry, I'm in the passenger seat), and not-so-typically for me, I'll be skippering this one! Although I primarily am a...

Hi! It's the end of July, which means my (metaphorical) desk right now is a pile of essay drafts from rising seniors, and I have to tell you, this batch is something. One student is connecting religion and science in a way that seems like it wouldn't fit until you actually read it closely. Another is finding that the writing process about her meditation practice itself has turned meditative. And there's a heart-moving piece on a summer at a vet clinic in a low-income neighborhood about facing...